Reference-Based Pricing Health Plans: Colorado Guide

Prepared by
Cooke & Associates
Read

Guide contents

    On this page

      At a glance

      • Not legal or tax advice: confirm filing specifics with your tax adviser

      Most renewal conversations in Colorado’s small group market come down to one number: the increase. Reference-based pricing health plans are one of the few strategies that change how a plan pays for care instead of moving more cost onto employees. It also carries a real trade-off, and you deserve to hear it before you sign anything.

      What a reference-based pricing health plan is

      A reference-based pricing (RBP) health plan sets a firm ceiling on what the plan will pay for a medical service. Your plan document decides the price instead of accepting the hospital’s billed charge or a carrier’s negotiated discount off that charge.

      The “reference” is almost always Medicare. Medicare publishes what it pays for each service in each part of the country, so the plan uses that figure as a yardstick and pays a set multiple of it.

      Compare that with a PPO, where the carrier’s network contract sets the price and the employer pays whatever the contract says. RBP is not a different kind of insurance company. It is a cost-control method used inside self-funded and level-funded plans, and it moves pricing decisions to the employer.

      How reference-based pricing actually works

      Diagram of a reference-based pricing claim: the plan sets a cap, the employee sees any doctor, the claim is repriced, then the provider is paid, negotiates, or sends a balance bill, which patient advo
      StepWhat happensWhat to watch
      1. Cap tied to MedicareThe plan pays a set multiple of Medicare, typically 120% to 300%The multiple varies by vendor and type of care
      2. No PPO networkEmployees can use any provider willing to accept the paymentThe network’s protection against balance billing is gone, unless the program is a hybrid
      3. Administrator reprices the claimA third-party administrator or pricing vendor calculates the allowed amount and pays the providerVendor quality varies widely
      4. Provider accepts, negotiates, or bills the memberMost claims close quietly, some are negotiated, a few end in a balance billStrong programs include patient advocacy and legal defense
      How reference-based pricing works, step by step

      Step 1: The plan sets a cap tied to Medicare

      The plan document names a multiple of Medicare as the allowed amount, typically between 120% and 300% of the Medicare rate depending on the vendor and the type of care. Inpatient stays, outpatient procedures, and physician services often carry different multiples. The multiple sits above Medicare on purpose, so the provider still earns a margin.

      Step 2: There is no traditional PPO network

      Employees can generally use any provider willing to accept the plan’s payment. There are no in-network or out-of-network tiers, so the penalty that catches people traveling or seeing a specialist disappears.

      The trade-off matters. A network contract is also what normally stops a hospital from billing the patient for whatever the plan did not pay. Without it, that protection has to come from somewhere else. Some programs are hybrid: they keep a network for doctors and apply RBP only to hospital and facility bills, where the largest dollars sit.

      Step 3: A third-party administrator reprices the claim

      A third-party administrator (the firm that processes claims for a self-funded plan) or a specialty pricing vendor receives the bill, calculates the allowed amount, and pays the provider. The same vendor issues ID cards, answers member calls, and fields provider questions.

      Hospitals keep a master list of charges that has little to do with what care costs. An RBP plan ignores that list and prices from Medicare instead.

      Step 4: The provider accepts, negotiates, or bills the member

      Many claims close without the employee hearing anything. Some providers come back and negotiate a settlement above the first payment, which the vendor handles. A few refuse and send the patient an invoice for the unpaid balance. That is balance billing, and it is the complaint you will hear most about these plans. Strong programs include patient advocacy and legal defense so the employee is not the one arguing with a billing office.

      Why hospital pricing makes this strategy work

      Infographic: knee procedure card branching to Hospital A and Hospital B, B's price bar nearly twice as tall

      The same procedure at two hospitals in the same metro area can carry very different prices, and the price often depends more on who is paying than on the care delivered. Commercial health plans generally pay hospitals well above what Medicare pays for identical services.

      Medicare rates make a workable yardstick because they are public, updated every year, and already adjusted for local wage and cost differences. An employer can point to a published number and explain exactly how a claim was priced. That is hard to do with a percentage discount off a charge nobody can verify.

      Reference-based pricing health plans vs. a traditional PPO plan

      PPOReference-based pricing
      Who sets the priceThe carrier’s network contractYour own plan document
      Where savings come fromA discount off an inflated chargeA cap tied to an outside benchmark (Medicare)
      Member experienceNetwork directory and predictable cost sharingOpen access, with possible friction at the billing desk
      Renewal mathA trend increase applied to premiumSpend that follows your actual claims
      HR workloadLowerHigher, especially in year one
      PPO vs. reference-based pricing

      The advantages for employers

      • Lower spend on hospital and facility claims, which drive most small group renewals.
      • Full visibility into how every claim was priced.
      • No network restrictions, so employees keep their own doctors and hospitals.
      • Savings stay in the plan instead of funding a carrier’s margin.
      • Freedom to adjust multiples, carve-outs, and benefits each year rather than picking from a menu.

      The risks nobody should gloss over

      Balance billing is the biggest drawback, and the one employees feel. Even when the vendor clears the bill, the employee has spent two weeks worried about it, and that story travels through a 25-person company fast.

      Some hospital systems push back harder than others, occasionally declining to schedule non-emergency care or asking for payment up front.

      RBP only works when employees know what to do before they schedule a procedure and what to do if a bill arrives, which makes communication part of the plan rather than an afterthought. Vendor quality varies widely, and the advocacy and legal defense terms are where the difference shows. A poorly matched RBP plan is worse than an unremarkable PPO.

      How balance billing risk gets managed

      Related readingGroup Health Insurance vs. Individual CoverageRead the guide →
      SafeguardWhat it does
      Member advocacy and legal defenseWritten into the vendor agreement at no cost to the employee
      One rule for employeesNever sign a financial responsibility form at the front desk without calling the plan first
      Price agreed before scheduled careFixes the number in advance for imaging, scopes, and joint replacement
      Written answer on billing protectionsConfirms how federal and Colorado rules apply to your plan, since self-funded plans don’t automatically fall under state insurance rules
      Balance billing safeguards

      Do reference-based pricing health plans fit a 2 to 60 employee Colorado business?

      RBP needs a self-funded or level-funded plan underneath it, so the first question is not “do we want RBP?” but “can this group support that structure?” Level-funded designs have opened that door to much smaller employers, which is why small Colorado companies are hearing about reference-based pricing at all.

      FactorGood fitPoor fit
      WorkforceStable, spread across several facilitiesVery small headcount
      Claims historyModerateOne or two high-cost claimants
      Hospital loyaltyOpen to different facilitiesStrong loyalty to one hospital system
      Owner and bandwidthOwner will stand behind the change and explain itNo bandwidth for employee education
      GeographyFront Range, where employees have options if one system resistsRural and mountain Colorado, where a county may have one hospital
      Is your group a fit for RBP?

      Geography matters. On the Front Range, employees have options if one system resists. In rural and mountain Colorado, where a county may have one hospital, that leverage disappears and exposure goes up.

      Worth pricing side by side with RBP: level-funded with a standard network, an arrangement that reimburses employees for individual coverage, narrow or tiered network designs, and a higher-deductible plan paired with a health reimbursement arrangement. Sometimes one of those wins.

      Questions to ask before you sign

      • What Medicare multiple applies to inpatient, outpatient, and physician claims?
      • Are patient advocacy and legal defense included, and truly free to the employee?
      • What share of claims produced a balance bill last year, and how many reached an employee?
      • Which Colorado hospital systems have refused this vendor’s payment before?
      • Who has authority to settle a disputed bill, and how fast?
      • Who runs employee education at launch and at every open enrollment?
      • If savings do not materialize, what does unwinding the plan look like at renewal?

      Timing: why this is a fourth-quarter conversation

      Most of the market renews for a new plan year in the fourth quarter, so decisions stack up in a short window. RBP needs more runway than a simple plan swap: plan document drafting, vendor selection, and employee meetings all take time, and education crammed into late December is how a sound strategy earns a bad reputation. Starting early also leaves room to walk away if the numbers do not hold up.

      That same review is the natural time to look at dental, vision, life, and short- and long-term disability. Those lines usually renew alongside medical and are easier to improve when they are priced together.

      Frequently asked questions

      Is reference-based pricing insurance?
      No. It’s a pricing method, not an insurance company or a different kind of coverage. It works inside a self-funded or level-funded health plan, where the plan document sets a cap on what the plan pays, usually a multiple of Medicare. That moves pricing decisions to the employer.
      Can employees keep their doctor?
      Usually, because there’s no network to leave. Employees can generally use any provider willing to accept the plan’s payment. Confirm the vendor’s history with the hospital systems your employees actually use, since some systems push back harder than others. Some programs are hybrids that keep a network for doctors and apply RBP only to hospital and facility bills.
      What should an employee do about a balance bill?
      Don’t pay it, don’t sign anything, and call the plan’s advocacy line the same day. The vendor can negotiate with the provider on the employee’s behalf, and strong programs include patient advocacy and legal defense at no cost to the employee. Also teach one rule up front: never sign a financial responsibility form at the front desk without calling the plan first.
      Does RBP work for a 15-person company?
      Sometimes. It needs a self-funded or level-funded plan underneath it, and level-funded designs have opened that door to smaller employers. Fit depends on funding structure and claims history, not headcount alone. A stable workforce and moderate claims help. One or two high-cost claimants in a very small group make it riskier.
      How much can we save?
      It depends on your claims mix. Savings come mostly from lower hospital and facility spend, which drives most small group renewals. Any figure quoted before someone has reviewed your census and current plan is a guess. Ask for a side-by-side quote against a standard level-funded plan and a fully insured option.
      Are reference-based pricing health plans allowed in Colorado?
      Yes. The rules that matter concern billing protections and plan administration, not the pricing method itself. Self-funded plans don’t automatically fall under state insurance rules, so get a written answer from your advisor and the vendor on how federal and Colorado billing protections apply to your plan.

      Get an honest read on whether RBP belongs in your plan

      Cooke & Associates is an independent consultant, not a captive of one carrier. The recommendation might be reference-based pricing, a level-funded plan with a network, a fully insured design, or leaving your plan alone this year.

      The process is straightforward. We gather your census, your current plan design, and what you are trying to accomplish, then quote and compare real options side by side and walk through them with you in person, by phone, or over Zoom.

      The part that matters most comes after the paperwork: employee education meetings, ID card follow-up, and claims and billing problems solved during the year. That is where most brokers go quiet. Take control of your benefits instead of letting a carrier set them for you. If your renewal is coming, start the conversation now.

      See more from Cook & Associates on Google

      Google's Preferred Sources lets you pick the sites you want to see more often in Top Stories. Add Cook & Associates and our new articles are more likely to show up when you search.

      Add Cook & Associates as a preferred source on Google

      Next step

      Not sure how this applies to your group?

      Request a strategy call and we will look at your plan designs and goals with you.

      Request a Strategy Call

      Get benefits support that stays with you throughout the year

      You do not have to manage rising costs, employee questions, claims issues, compliance concerns, and annual renewals alone.

      Request a Strategy Call